Here is the full meaning of these acronyms – HIRA and JSA
HIRA means – Hazard Identification and Risk Assessment
JSA – Job Safety Analysis
Before we state the difference between HIRA and JSA, let’s give an overview of each acronym.
HIRA – Hazard Identification and Risk Assessment
HIRA is a hazard identification technique. It is a structured method for detecting and evaluating hazards in process facilities/systems. HIRA helps detect potential risks that may cause accidents, injuries, or environmental damage.
The initial focus is to identify potential hazards within a process, while the secondary step is to assess the process-related risks according to certain evaluation factors.
The initial aspect focuses on physical inspections of equipment and handling procedures within the workspace areas and processes to identify potential risks to human health and safety.
The second phase, the risk assessment phase, starts by determining how the hazardous events generate certain impacts. Not uncommonly, these impacts are related to human safety, environmental disturbance, and/or asset damage/loss of production. In some cases, also reputational impact can be part of the assessment if found necessary. The risk assessment is the process where identified hazardous risks are evaluated in terms of their severity, likelihood, and other factors.
JSA – Job Safety Analysis
Job safety analysis is a process that helps assess a job to identify hazards and necessary control measures. In a job safety analysis, each basic step of the job is broken down into steps to identify potential hazards and to recommend the safest way to do the job.
We can also say that Job Safety Analysis (JSA) is a systematic procedure that breaks each job/task into key training sequences, identifies safety elements of each job/task step and coaches the employee on how to avoid potential safety hazards. It is also called a Job Hazard Analysis or JHA.
Here are the benefits of JSA:
- Ensuring consistent and safe work methods.
- Reducing injuries by helping employees know how to best perform a task without the likelihood of injury.
- Provides a form of training documentation regarding the employee’s knowledge of the job safety requirements.
- Complies with many OSHA requirements.
Difference Between HIRA and JSA
| HIRA – Hazard Identification and Risk Assessment | JSA – Job Safety Analysis | ||
|
A step-by-step analysis of specific job tasks to identify hazards and control measures. | ||
| 2. Broad and covers all activities, equipment, and processes in a workplace. | Narrow and focuses on individual job tasks. | ||
| 3. Risk management for the overall workplace. | Hazard identification and prevention in specific tasks. | ||
| 4. Proactive; involves assessing potential risks before they occur. | Task-specific; emphasizes safety in operational steps. | ||
|
Used to enhance safety in daily job activities. | ||
| 6. Comprehensive risk assessment document. | Step-by-step procedure document for a task. | ||
| 7. Suitable for large-scale activities and projects. | Ideal for repetitive or critical tasks requiring precision. | ||
| 8. Conducted periodically or during significant changes. | Conducted before executing a specific job task. | ||
| 9. Performed by safety professionals, supervisors, and sometimes external consultants. | Involves workers performing the task and their supervisors. | ||
| 10. To reduce workplace risks and ensure compliance with safety standards. | To ensure the safe execution of specific tasks. |
Conclusion
Though both HIRA and JSA fall under the same category of work safety, their purposes differ. It encompasses risk identification and its management at every workplace level proactively to avoid incidents and ensure that compliance is maintained according to regulations.
The approach of JSA, in turn, focuses on particular tasks with the purpose of breaking them down into steps and working out where in each step the hazards might come from and how controls must be implemented.
While HIRA emphasizes a broad perspective that is suitable for large projects and organizational planning, JSA looks at task-level safety to ensure the protection of workers in the everyday activities of the operation. Together, they complement a system for effectiveness in workplace safety.
Related Post
Discover the Foundations of Health and Safety
What Is The Difference Between Job Safety Analysis (JSA) And Risk Assessment
How to Write a Good Health and Safety Policy
